— Buying tools
The Florida insurance reality.
Insurance is the line item that has killed more Florida deals in the last three years than any other. Wind, flood, Citizens, surplus lines, 4-point inspections, wind mitigation discounts — this page covers what buyers actually need to know.
The four coverage types
- HO-3 (homeowners) policy. The standard. Covers structure, contents, liability, additional living expense. In Florida this usually INCLUDES wind/hail unless you live in a designated wind-pool zone (mostly barrier islands and parts of the coastal corridor) where wind is sometimes carved out and written separately.
- Wind policy (when carved out). For homes in wind-pool zones, wind is written as a separate policy — often through Citizens (the state-backed insurer of last resort) or a surplus-lines carrier. Can easily double total premium.
- Flood insurance. Separate from your homeowners policy in nearly all cases. NFIP (federal) is the default; private flood is increasingly competitive and worth quoting. Required by lenders for any home in AE, VE, A, or V flood zones. Strongly recommended in X zones near water — most "flooded homes" in 2022's Hurricane Ian were in X zones.
- Sinkhole + catastrophic ground cover collapse. Florida-specific. CGCC coverage is required by statute on all HO-3s. Full sinkhole rider is optional and significantly more expensive — relevant in parts of Hernando, Pasco, Citrus, and some inland Hillsborough.
Critical timing
Get insurance quotes BEFORE you make an offer, not after inspection. A 1995-roof waterfront home in a VE zone can be uninsurable through standard carriers — meaning surplus-lines pricing 2-3x what you budgeted. By the time you find out at week 4, you may have already lost your inspection contingency window.
Citizens, private, surplus — what's the difference?
Standard private carriers (State Farm, Universal, Kin, Tower Hill, etc.) are your best-case outcome — competitive rates, the most billing flexibility, no special filings.
Citizens Property Insurance is the state-backed insurer of last resort. Cheaper than surplus lines but the state has been actively pushing “depopulation” — if a private carrier comes within 20% of Citizens' rate, you can be removed. Plan on it.
Surplus lines (Lloyd's, certain non-admitted carriers) are the safety net beyond Citizens — homes the standard market won't touch (old roof, prior claims, high coastal exposure). Pricing can be 2-4x standard. No state guarantee fund backing — read the policy carefully.
What changed in 2022 + 2023
- AOB (assignment of benefits) reform — closes the loophole that drove most of the post-2017 litigation explosion. Means more carriers willing to write Florida policies, but premiums took years to settle.
- One-way attorney fees eliminated — homeowners no longer auto-recover legal fees in disputes with insurers. Reduces fraud but also reduces leverage in legitimate claim disputes.
- Citizens depopulation push — Citizens is required to offer policyholders to private carriers if a private offer comes within 20% of the Citizens rate. Read your renewal mail carefully.
- My Safe Florida Home program — state-funded wind mitigation inspections and matching grants for hurricane hardening (impact windows, roof straps). Worth applying if you buy older.
The 4-point inspection
Required by most insurers for homes 20-30+ years old. Inspector evaluates four systems; carriers use the report to decide whether to bind.
- Roof. Age, material, remaining life. Insurers prefer 15 years or less. Most non-standard markets refuse to write at 20+ years old regardless of condition.
- Electrical. Panel brand, breaker condition, knob-and-tube absence. Federal Pacific and Zinsco panels are insurance dealbreakers — plan for $2-3K replacement before closing.
- Plumbing. Supply line material (polybutylene is a dealbreaker for most carriers), drain condition, water heater age.
- HVAC. Age, condition, signs of leaks. Most carriers cap acceptable age around 15-20 years.
Wind mitigation = real money
A separate inspection that documents hurricane hardening features. Each qualifying feature reduces premium. Stacked, the discounts can cut your wind premium by 30-50%.
- Hip-shaped roof (vs. gable) — significant discount.
- Secondary water resistance — peel-and-stick membrane under shingles. Big discount.
- Roof-to-wall connection — clips, single wraps, or double wraps. The stronger, the bigger the discount.
- Opening protection — impact windows, impact doors, or accordion / panel shutters covering all openings.
- Roof deck attachment — nailed vs. nail-and-glue (Florida code requires the better attachment on new roofs since 2002).
“Insurance has caught more buyers off guard in the last two years than any other line item. Quote it before the offer; budget the worst case.”
— Ben Laube
Need a real quote on a real house?
I work with a handful of FL independent agents who quote across 30+ carriers. Send a property address; I'll get you 3-5 quotes back inside a week.